Our professional and experienced team is ready to provide you with solutions that address your client needs. This includes traditional insurance products, alternative solutions, captives and more.
Chris Murray has been President of Caitlin Morgan Insurance Services since 2006. He is responsible for providing strategic leadership for the company by working with management and vendor partners to establish long-range goals, strategies, plans and policies.
Chris has more than 22 years of experience in the Alternative Risk Financing industry. He has managed various alternative risk insurance programs from Self-Insurance to Captive Programs.
Chris serves as President and Chairman of the Board for Midwest Insurance Group, Inc, a Risk Retention Group domiciled in Vermont. He also serves as Vice President with M.R. Mead and Company, a well-respected captive management company.
In addition, Chris serves as Vice Present of Constitution Insurance Company, LLC, a segregated cell captive domiciled in Tennessee.
Chris works closely with the Indiana Nursing Home Associations and serves as a board member of the Indiana Healthcare Foundation, a non-profit charity offering scholarships to those in the healthcare industry.
He served on the board of directors of the Arizona Captive Insurance Association and later served as President of the association.
Chris obtained his undergraduate degree from Butler University where he majored in accounting and later obtained his CPA designation in 1995.
Senior Vice President
Along with his extensive experience working in alternative risk Dustin’s 10 plus years working with risk retention groups and captive insurance companies will bring added horsepower to an already robust Caitlin Morgan Insurance Services (CM Captives) team.
Recently Dustin served as the Director of Captive Management Operations at Hylant Administrative Services, and previously as Director at JLT Towner Insurance Management. Dustin is a Certified Public Accountant and is a member of the American Institute for Certified Public Accountants, the Vermont Society of Public Accountants and the Vermont Captive Insurance Association. Dustin joins Caitlin Morgan’s captive management team through its Captive Management Division.
John Haigerty began his tenure as Vice President of Sales and Marketing at Caitlin Morgan Insurance Services in 2010. John is responsible for marketing the Caitlin Morgan Insurance Services brand through constant interaction with the firm’s valued retail agency partners. He is involved in establishing sales growth initiatives while optimizing the effectiveness of the programs and products offered by Caitlin Morgan to the market place.
John offers strong experience and knowledge in alternative risk solutions, especially associated with the ISESC Public School Risk Management Program, Health Select, an Employee Benefits Stop-Loss Captive, and several of Caitlin Morgan’s exclusive Healthcare Programs.
John earned his B.S. at Indiana University, Kelley School of Business, and is a Certified Insurance Counselor.
John and his wife live and work in Indianapolis, where they are raising four sons.
Gerry Dumke has been the Vice President of Underwriting at Caitlin Morgan Insurance Services since 2006. He is responsible for overseeing all wholesale brokerage activities, including program underwriting and placement of business. He works directly with agents as well as being the point of contact for contracted carriers and reinsurers. Gerry also contributes in the contracting of new markets and development of program opportunities. He assists with larger risk placement including large deductible and self-insurance policies. In addition, Gerry is involved with the creation and execution of executive management decisions regarding the enhancement of Caitlin Morgan’s growth.
Gerry has been involved in the insurance industry for almost 20 years working in various roles with insurance carriers, Third Party Administrators, and MGAs. His roles have included Marketing and Branding of new insurance carrier territories, planting of agencies and relationship development, Captive Underwriting, and Production Underwriting focused on growth and profitability. He also managed a group of underwriters including training and oversight, while working closely with claims and loss control to maintain profitability on a multi-state book of business.
Prior to entering the insurance industry, Gerry was involved in banking working as a Money Center Officer, tasked with setting loan and savings rates, assisting in the management of the bank’s investment portfolio and managing the day-to-day cash in order to maximize returns. He was involved in asset management committee meetings to help set bank strategy and budgeting with an emphasis on quantitative analysis.
Gerry earned his undergraduate degree, BS in Finance, from Butler University.
Clint began his insurance career in 2001 after graduating from Ball State University with a degree in Business Administration. He served as a life/health and property/casualty insurance agent for the first 3 years of his career. In 2004 Clint purchased Indiana Surplus Lines Insurance where he transitioned to President and Commercial Underwriter until 2011, when he sold to City Financial Corp. From 2011 until 2016, Clint maintained his position as President of the ISL division, while focusing his attention on marketing and commercial underwriting. In September of 2016, Clint joined Caitlin Morgan Insurance Services to oversee the growth and underwriting integrity of the wholesale P & C and Nursing Home RRG book.
Clint is a graduate of the Cincinnati Insurance Company’s School of Commercial Insurance, has held the coveted Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation since 2010, has been a proud supporter of the Independent Insurance Agents of Indiana and Indiana Young Agent Committee since 2004, is a past Young Agent of the Year Award winner (2011), and also served as Chairman of the Indiana Young Agents (2013-2014).
Lara Engelking of Engelking Law Group, LLC devotes her practice to defense of nursing homes, nurses, physicians, and other health care organizations throughout the state of Indiana in professional liability litigation. Her practice is uniquely devoted only to the defense of “qualified providers” who participate in the Indiana Patient’s Compensation Fund.
Lara also holds the position of Director of Healthcare Litigation Services for Caitlin Morgan Insurance Services, Inc., an insurance wholesaler and program manager for the Midwest Insurance Group; A Risk Retention Group that insures nursing homes across the state of Indiana; as well as the Doctor’s Insurance Group, which focuses on medical malpractice for physicians. In her role as Director of Healthcare Litigation Services, Lara oversees professional liability litigation.
She is also a registered nurse and a frequent lecturer and speaks both at the local and national levels on topics related to Professional Liability and Licensure matters for Healthcare Providers, Tort Reform, and The Indiana Medical Malpractice Act. She is active with the national American Association of Nurse Attorneys, where she previously served as a Board member for three years as well as Treasurer of the organization.
Stan Murray, Founder and Partner of Caitlin Morgan Insurance Services since 1989, is responsible for providing strategic leadership for the company by working with management and vendor partners to establish long-range goals, strategies, plans and policies. Stan has more than 46 years of experience in the Insurance and Alternative Risk industry. He has managed various alternative risk insurance programs from Self-Insurance to Group Self Insurance Programs.
Stan is Vice President of the Board for Midwest Insurance Group, Inc., a Risk Retention Group domiciled in Vermont. Stan also served as President of a mono-line insurance company responsible for overall corporate direction including financial structure, product development, marketing, underwriting, loss control, claims and staff management.
Stan is responsible for structuring self-insurance pool programs for both public and private entities, establishing plan structure, excess placement, underwriting controls, secure loss control and claims management services, contracting negotiations, and monitoring of services; and individual client risk management consulting services for self-funded workers’ compensation.
In addition, he developed the first captive self-insurance group in Indiana, served as Past Fund Manager for three Illinois self-insured groups, and Past Program Manager for two rent-a-captive programs that operated in 26 states.
Stan obtained his undergraduate degree from Purdue University and later did graduate work at Butler University. Stan holds an Associate in Risk Management designation.
Contact the experts at Caitlin-Morgan today and experience the benefits of working with a new kind of MGU and wholesale brokerage. For more information, call 317-575-4440 or
Stay up to date with our Editor’s Picks blogposts.